The Loophole in UK Fertility Law: How Sperm Banks Circumvent the 10-Family Limit
The UK is known for its relatively progressive and well-regulated fertility sector. One of the most important safeguards in place is the “10 family limit” — a rule that restricts a sperm donor’s genetic contribution to no more than ten families within the UK. This rule was designed to protect donor-conceived individuals from accidentally meeting and forming relationships with their half-siblings, and to maintain ethical standards within donor programs.
But there’s a major loophole that’s rarely discussed outside the fertility world: the rule only applies within the UK. Once donor sperm is exported to another country, the limit no longer applies. As a result, a donor’s sperm could be used in dozens or even hundreds of families worldwide, while still appearing compliant under UK law.
Why the 10-Family Limit Exists
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) introduced the 10-family limit to prevent a variety of problems:
-
Reducing the risk of accidental consanguinity (unintentional relationships between donor siblings)
-
Maintaining diversity within the donor pool
-
Protecting donor-conceived children’s right to a manageable number of genetic relatives
Before the 10-family limit, there were cases where a single donor’s sperm was used in dozens or even hundreds of births, raising ethical, psychological, and medical concerns. Public and professional pressure led the UK government to impose a cap, with most fertility clinics adopting the rule since 1991 and it becoming standard under HFEA regulation.
The Export Loophole
While the 10-family limit is enforced for treatments within the UK, it does not apply to sperm that is exported to fertility clinics abroad. UK-based sperm banks are legally allowed to ship donor sperm to other countries, and when they do, there is no legal limit on how many families it can be used for internationally.
This means that a donor who reaches the 10-family maximum in the UK can still have sperm sent abroad to be used in unlimited additional families. The result is that often there is no way for donor-conceived children to know how many genetic half-siblings exist or where they are.
Some key concerns:
-
Donor-conceived people may be unaware of the true scale of their genetic network
-
Exported samples may not be subject to the same consent or identity disclosure rules
-
The practice undermines the spirit of the 10-family limit
A Global Footprint, No Global Oversight
Fertility is a cross-border business, but regulation is still overwhelmingly national. This leaves large gaps in accountability. UK donors may be told their sperm will only be used for 10 families, but unless they ask specific questions, they may not realize that their donations can (and often do) travel abroad.
Meanwhile, donor-conceived children and their parents may believe they are part of a small, defined group of half-siblings, only to discover years later that the truth is far more complicated.
What Needs to Change
If the UK truly intends to uphold the ethical standards behind the 10-family rule, it must address the export loophole. Possible reforms include:
-
Requiring full transparency to donors and recipients about export practices
-
Applying a global limit to the number of families per donor, regardless of country
-
Mandating that exported donations be tracked and reported through HFEA
-
Creating international agreements to harmonize donor use and disclosure rules
Until these measures are in place, the UK’s 10-family limit may look good on paper, but its practical impact will remain limited.
In Summary
The UK’s 10-family limit was a thoughtful and ethical response to legitimate concerns about the overuse of donor sperm. But in today’s global fertility market, loopholes like unrestricted exports have rendered the limit far less effective than intended. For the sake of transparency, accountability, and the rights of donor-conceived people, it’s time to close the gap between intention and reality.
